First Commonwealth Bank
Bank · #333 by purchase decisions in 2025 · Conventional 85%.
approved of 1,034 decisions.
Approval by DTI band
Each row is approved versus denied among files whose decision used that ratio. Read the 50–60% row against the ≤43% row: a gap is the signature of a wall at 50.
Conventional
| DTI band | Decisions | Approved · denied | Denials citing DTI |
|---|---|---|---|
| ≤43% | 808 | 3% | |
| 44–45% | 79 | 50% | |
| 46–49% | 137 | 0% |
Rates and costs
Compared with the national market in the same LTV band and points-paid cell; 30-year fixed conforming purchase loans. Builder-owned lenders buy rates down as a sales incentive, which is paid for in the house price.
Where it lends
Pennsylvania (675), Ohio (508), Kentucky (12), Florida (4), Indiana (3), Georgia (2), North Carolina (1), Delaware (1), West Virginia (1), Minnesota (1).
Compare First Commonwealth Bank with every lender in a state on the approvals, rates and fees pages.
Questions
Does First Commonwealth Bank approve loans with a DTI over 50%?
First Commonwealth Bank decided too few purchase files above 50% DTI in 2025 to report a rate. The table on this page shows every band.
Are First Commonwealth Bank's rates competitive?
In 2025 its closed conventional loans were priced 4 basis points below the market median after matching LTV band and points paid.
Why does First Commonwealth Bank deny applications?
Too few denials were reported to describe a pattern.
Where does this come from?
First Commonwealth Bank's own 2025 HMDA filing, as published by the CFPB. Purchase loans on site-built, one-unit, owner-occupied homes. Decisions, not policy: files screened out before a formal application never appear. Credit score is withheld from the public file.
Method
Approvals from the approvals dataset (originated vs. denied by DTI band). Rates: HMDA interest rate on 30-year fixed conforming purchase originations, compared cell by cell with the national market. Costs: Closing Disclosure total loan costs, binned to $250. Denial reasons: first reason listed on denied files. Lender type assigned from the name.
Corrections
Every figure traces to First Commonwealth Bank’s own filing. If a number looks wrong, write to us and we will re-run it.
Who said yes above 50% DTI: the 2025 lender sheet
2.9 million purchase decisions from 2,523 lenders, ranked by approval rate at 50–60% DTI. One page per state, conventional / FHA / VA. Nobody else publishes it:
- The lenders in your state that actually approve high-ratio files, with the decision count behind every percentage
- Which ones are lenient everywhere and which only above 50%, so you know who to call first
- Builder lenders flagged, so a buydown-fed 95% doesn’t fool you
Check your inbox. Click the confirmation link and the lender sheet arrives right after. If it isn’t there in a minute, look in spam — that’s where it usually is.
You’ll also get one email a month on what actually changed in mortgage rules and costs, written by a licensed loan officer with the math shown. Unsubscribe in one click, any time. Privacy Policy.